Loyalty Trends and DTC Referral Flywheels with Smile CEO Mike Rossi

Loyalty Trends and DTC Referral Flywheels with Smile CEO Mike Rossi

Adrian Alfieri
Adrian Alfieri
CEO, Verbatim

Mike Rossi is the co-founder and CEO of Smile.io, the loyalty programs platform running points, rewards, and referrals for nearly a decade. Their 50,000+ clients run the gauntlet from small businesses to category-defining names like Polaroid, Topps, and Inkbox.

We sat down with Mike to discuss Smile’s transition from an agency model into a lucrative eCom tool, when brands should kickstart rewards, and how to build long-lasting communities.

“Our goal is to help as many brands as possible through frictionless onboarding and a killer product. In turn, Smile can position itself as a low-cost, low-effort tool delivering repeat sales for every brand we partner with.”

Shifting Focus: Agency to eCom Tool

In the early 2010s, the Smile.io team was an agency that assisted brands and merchants running on Magento, the eCom platform by Adobe. They built Magento Extensions for clients, which were essentially various features and integrations for stores — including one for loyalty programs that could be easily installed by any merchant on the web.

The team sold this extension as a low-level product company while continuing to operate as an agency until the wave of eCom tooling and general user demand — clients’ ad spend was ramping up while retention decreased — led to a full-time shift toward Smile.io as it is now.

In terms of the transition in business model, an agency with a notable number of clients demonstrating interest in a potential product likely already possesses the necessary validation for a strong product-market fit.

After all, shifting out of an agency model means you very likely already have a user pool that wants to pay for this product, especially when compared to someone starting from scratch in terms of product validation or sales relationship building.

However, more difficulties can arise in terms of cash flow and operations. For instance, the cash flow model for an agency entails cash committed upfront for labor, while products require essentially taking a gamble by investing an amount of capital and hoping to see ROI over time.

“If you have close relationships with your clients, you’re in a much better position to know what the market wants compared to someone on the outside looking in.”

When to Optimize Reward Timelines

When asked at what point brands should begin establishing loyalty programs for customers, Mike insists it varies among categories. He described a matrix that the Smile team utilizes, with natural purchase frequency on one axis and profit margins on the other.

A product that has high profit margins and low purchase frequency — such as cars, boats, and other vehicles — is naturally illogical for any type of rewards program for repeat purchases.

However, a product with lower margins and greater purchase frequency, i.e. foods or cleaning supplies, is far more ideal for rewarding frequent purchases and thus priming for brand loyalty.

Smile, therefore, recommends loyalty programs for businesses that fall into the latter bucket — and subsequently have greater likelihoods for success with the platform. For example, repeat purchase rates after onboarding with Smile increase by 20% on average in six months.

But Mike says the structure of the Smile platform — little-to-no cost, setup, and maintenance, with low risk and high potential reward — means rewards don’t have to be restricted to mature brands, as would be the case for a more complicated or pricey loyalty program.

Early businesses receiving as few as 10+ purchases per month can begin to reward customers while receiving 100+ monthly purchases is an ideal entry point for a Smile loyalty program.

“We’ve designed Smile to be intuitive across setup and maintenance, so I’d really feel comfortable recommending it for any stage of a brand’s growth journey.”

A Tool for Scaling DTC Communities

In Mike’s opinion, many brands have grown heavy-handed in using community as a buzzword or default method for building, or perhaps forcing, brand identity and a loyal user base — without a solid product to justify it.

Instead, the Smile team considers a user community to be the final outcome of other foundational brand components done well, such as an evergreen product, organic social materials, thorough post-purchase and return experiences, and so on.

Within that user flow, rewards should convert a user who’s simply had a positive purchase into one who’s impressed enough to return.

This then helps catalyze a population of customers who are high in repeat purchase and brand enthusiasm, AKA community members.

That community can then be solidified by whatever method organically suits the brand at hand, whether that’s Instagram comment sections, in-person meetups, or pop-up shops.

“Community is wildly overused right now. If you make something cool and help facilitate folks that want to meet each other, a community will naturally form.”

The Future of the eCom Tech Stack

For early eCom brands attempting to assemble or retool their tech stacks in a time where the ecosystem feels entirely inundated with options, Mike recommends basing your degree of experimentation and iteration on the maturity, and potentially the vertical, of your company.

In his words, a young brand can and should be iterating with numerous tooling options on a consistent basis to gauge which elements click best with both your model and your customers.

The faster you can iterate, the faster you can get to your ideal, tailored tech stack.

Once a brand matures, however, the opportunity to tinker with a stack grows more expensive and can risk a customer’s user experience. In this case, Mike strongly cautions against too many tooling stack adjustments, when dollars and time could instead be directed elsewhere.

Put simply, too little iteration early on and too much iteration at a later phase can both be equally damaging to your brand’s overall health and ability to scale over time.

“A lot of brands are in need of new competitive advantages — and Skio has been particularly great at pushing out quick iterations for subscriptions. My personal confidence in their degree of innovation was definitely a reason for investing.”

Adrian Alfieri
Adrian Alfieri
CEO, Verbatim
  • AI CMO Launch
    AI CMO Launch
    (Tier 1 Viral)
    Introducing Icon, the world's first AI CMO (Chief Marketing Officer).
  • $12M Domain
    $12M Domain
    (Tier 1 Domain)
    The icon.com domain is the 6th most expensive domain of all time (thus making it a Tier 1 Domain).
  • Ridge
    Mudwtr
    Gruns
    Obvi
    Atlas Coffee Club
    Gwella

    Examples

    5 ad types: Google Veo, AI Creator + B-roll, Testimonials, B-roll only, & Static.
    G
    gruns
    Google Veo
    M
    marissaren
    AI Creator + B-roll
    D
    drinkabrez
    Testimonial
    T
    tryarmra
    Static
    tryarmra sponsored content

    How AdGPT works

    (AI-assisted)
    • 1. Turn your assets into legos
      1. Turn your assets into legos
      Icon looks at your asset library & tags video scenes + images (e.g. "unboxing"). Tagged assets are lego blocks for making ads.
    • 2. Create ads with AdGPT
      2. Create ads with AdGPT
      Use AdGPT Workflows to create video + static ads that are 0-99% complete. Video ads have matching clips for every scene.
    • 3. Edit with AdCut & Canvas
      3. Edit with AdCut & Canvas
      Use AdCut (AI Video Editor) & Canvas (AI Image Editor) to edit your 0-99% complete AdGPT ads if needed.
    • 4. Replace $2K-$30K/mo
      4. Replace $2K-$30K/mo
      Combine 12 products into 1 for just $39+/mo (replaces $2K-$30K/mo).

    AdGPT Workflows

    Create video + static ads that are 0-99% complete.
    Workflows are available in 3 completion levels (high, medium, low). With a high completion level, Icon does more work.
    • Make me an ad
      Make me an ad
      High completion
      Save time by getting winning ads from AI CMO.
      For: Static Ads, Video Ads
    • Clone ad
      Clone ad
      High completion
      Save time by cloning winning ads from top brands & competitors.
      For: Static Ads, Video Ads
    • Ad from existing UGC
      Ad from existing UGC
      High completion
      Save time by creating testimonial ads from existing UGC.
      For: Static Ads, Video Ads
    • B-roll cutting
      B-roll cutting
      High completion
      Save time by cutting in B-roll on your UGC videos.
      For: Video Ads
    • Ad from deep research
      Ad from deep research
      Medium completion
      Save time by creating ads from ad concepts we find (that you pick).
      For: Static Ads, Video Ads
    • Ad from prompt
      Ad from prompt
      Low completion
      Save time by creating ads from prompts (think ChatGPT for ads).
      For: Static Ads, Video Ads

    How AI CMO works

    (automated)
    • 1. Get winning ad concepts
      1. Get winning ad concepts
      Icon finds winning ad concepts by scanning websites & publicly running ads (yours & competitors), ad account performance, & more.
    • 2. Review winning AI CMO ads
      2. Review winning AI CMO ads
      AI CMO copies what worked for competitors, tries fresh approaches, & scales your winners.
    • 3. Edit ads if needed
      3. Edit ads if needed
      AI CMO ads are 50-99% complete. Use AdCut (AI Video Editor) & Canvas (AI Image Editor) to edit them if needed.
    • 4. Download ads you like
      4. Download ads you like
      Download ads or upload them into your ad accounts with 1 click.

    Us vs. them

    Just $39+/mo for 14-products-in-1 (replaces $2K-$30K/mo). No one else comes close.
    Unlimited ad creations, custom assets, & edits.
    3-day free trial & 100% money-back guarantee, no questions asked.
    Replaces ChatGPT, CapCut, Canva, Claude, AdCreative, Motion, Foreplay, Recharm, Sora, Kling, Air, Frame.io, Creatify, Atria, HeyGen, Arcads, MakeUGC, Soona, AdManage, Adscook, & more.
    Icon
    ChatGPT
    CapCut
    Managed service ($1500/mo+)
    check
    x
    x
    GoogleGoogle Veo ads
    check
    x
    x
    3-day free trial
    check
    check
    check
    100% money-back guarantee
    check
    x
    x
    Made for ads
    check
    x
    x
    Ad creation workflows (AdGPT)
    check
    x
    x
    AI CMO (Chief Marketing Officer)
    check
    x
    x
    Video ad generator
    check
    x
    x
    Video editor
    check
    x
    check
    AI-generated UGC
    check
    x
    x
    AI-generated B-roll
    check
    x
    x
    Static ad generator
    check
    check
    x
    Image editor
    check
    x
    x
    Product distortions autocorrected
    check
    x
    x
    Competitor ad cloning
    check
    x
    x
    Scriptwriting + creative briefs
    check
    check
    x
    Audience research
    check
    x
    x
    Creative storage
    check
    x
    x
    AI asset tagging & splitting
    check
    x
    x
    Hook A/B testing
    check
    x
    x
    Creative analytics
    check
    x
    x
    Ad Manager uploads
    check
    x
    x
    Desktop app (macOS, Windows)
    check
    check
    check
    Tier 1 CEO, investors, engineers
    check
    check
    x
    $12M .com domain (tier 1)
    check
    x
    x
    7-day work week
    check
    x
    x
    Founded 2025
    check
    x
    x

    Products

    14-products-in-1 for just $39+/mo (replaces $2K-$30K/mo). Built by our Tier 1 Engineering Team.
    3-day free trial & 100% money-back guarantee, no questions asked.
    Replaces ChatGPT, CapCut, Canva, Claude, AdCreative, Motion, Foreplay, Recharm, Sora, Kling, Air, Frame.io, Creatify, Atria, HeyGen, Arcads, MakeUGC, Soona, AdManage, Adscook, & more.

    What they're saying

    Obvi
    "We went from spending hours making each ad to building entire campaigns in minutes. Icon helps us shape perfect creatives at incredible speed."
    Ron Shah

    Ron Shah

    CEO, Obvi
    $100M+ revenue

    Story

    Kennan Davison

    Kennan Davison

    CEO, Founder
    Kennan Davison
    Kennan Davison
    Kennan Davison
    Kennan Davison
    Kennan Davison
    College dropout. Solo-founded Skio ($15M+ ARR & profitable, $8M seed, 50+ teammates).
    Top 200 NA League of Legends (100M+ players), YC S20 (solo), W+K (ad agency), Columbia (instant dropout).
    Hi, I'm Kennan!
    Thank you for reading this. My life has been a journey full of ups & downs & I’m grateful to be here.
    I grew up finding school extremely boring & slept through most of my classes. If I'm being real, no one thought I'd go anywhere (was Top 200 North America out of 100M+ players in League of Legends though).
    Everything changed when I was 18: I had a big wakeup call & had to start supporting myself.
    This triggered me in a good way & I worked 100-hour weeks until I destroyed coding interviews. Soon after, I dropped out of college after 1 year to join Pinterest (youngest employee).
    After being a minion at Pinterest, I quit cold turkey & started my 1st company, Skio. I fluked into Y Combinator as a solo founder & completely failed during the batch. Thankfully, pivoting worked well ($15M+ ARR & profitable, $8M seed, 50+ teammates).
    But it's not over yet: I've started Icon because I have a massive chip on my shoulder.
    I know I’m not supposed to say this publicly, but I want to make Icon the greatest company of all time.
    I want to deliver insane value to our customers.
    I want to create generational wealth for my team & investors.
    I want to break the $0 to $100M ARR world record.
    I want to make the $12M I spent on the icon.com domain worth it.
    I want to win so bad that I'm sacrificing my life working 7 days a week for it. I'll even eat dog poop if it means winning.
    We're 2 months in & have lots to live up to. Feel free to give feedback anytime at kennan@icon.com.

    Investors (Tier 1 VCs)

    Our Tier 1 Investors helped us hire a Tier 1 Engineering Team (results in Tier 1 Products).
    Peter Thiel's Founders Fund & execs of frontier AI labs like OpenAI, Cognition, & Pika.
    Founders Fund

    Founders Fund

    Icon Investor
    Founders Fund
    Founders Fund
    Founders Fund
    Founders Fund
    Founders Fund
    Founders Fund
    Peter Thiel's venture capital firm.
    Mark Chen

    Mark Chen

    Icon Investor
    Mark Chen
    Mark Chen
    Mark Chen
    Mark Chen
    Chief Research Officer at OpenAI (ChatGPT).
    Saquon Barkley

    Saquon Barkley

    Icon Investor
    Saquon Barkley
    Saquon Barkley
    NFL Running Back Philadelphia Eagles (Super Bowl 2025).
    Roman Khan

    Roman Khan

    Icon Investor
    Roman Khan
    Roman Khan
    Roman Khan
    Roman Khan
    Roman Khan
    CMO at Raycon, Know Beauty, & Linjer.

    Team (Tier 1)

    Our Tier 1 Engineering Team is by far the best in the space.
    From Google, Facebook, Pinterest, Snap, & more. 7-day work week. Remote banned.
    Kennan Davison

    Kennan Davison

    CEO, Founder
    Kennan Davison
    Kennan Davison
    Kennan Davison
    Kennan Davison
    Kennan Davison
    College dropout. Solo-founded Skio ($15M+ ARR & profitable, $8M seed, 50+ teammates), Top 200 NA LoL, YC S20.
    Yunyu Lin

    Yunyu Lin

    Founding Board Member
    Yunyu Lin
    Yunyu Lin
    Yunyu Lin
    Yunyu Lin
    Yunyu Lin
    Yunyu Lin
    Yunyu Lin
    CEO, Co-founder at Penrose, Head of AI at Ramp, CEO at Cohere (acq. by Ramp), Nuro, Facebook, YC S20, Duke (dropout).
    Kevin Jin

    Kevin Jin

    Engineering
    Kevin Jin
    Kevin Jin
    Kevin Jin
    Kevin Jin
    Kevin Jin
    Kevin Jin
    CTO at Kalder, Robinhood, Rippling, Impira, Flexport, Google, Tesla, TSM, Vanderbilt.
    Max Sidebotham

    Max Sidebotham

    Engineering
    Max Sidebotham
    Max Sidebotham
    Max Sidebotham
    Max Sidebotham
    CTO, Co-founder at Tare (AI Emails / LLMs), Founding Engineer at Skio, Robinhood, UMD.

    Agency Directory (Tier 1 Agencies)

    Get clients for your agency. We get 1M+ monthly views from brands looking for more creative volume.
    GR0

    GR0

    Monthly ads created
    1000
    Monthly adspend
    $10M+
    Avenue Z

    Avenue Z

    Monthly ads created
    1000
    Monthly adspend
    $10M+

    Explore more

  • AI CMO Launch
    AI CMO Launch
    (Tier 1 Viral)
    Introducing Icon, the world's first AI CMO (Chief Marketing Officer).
  • $12M Domain
    $12M Domain
    (Tier 1 Domain)
    The icon.com domain is the 6th most expensive domain of all time (thus making it a Tier 1 Domain).
  • Ready to plan, create, & run 1000s of winning ads end-to-end?

    Just $39+/mo for 14-products-in-1 (replaces $2K-$30K/mo).
    3-day free trial & 100% money-back guarantee, no questions asked.
    Icon: The AI Admaker

    Icon: The AI Admaker

    5.02288+ happy brands
    Plan, create, & run 1000s of winning ads end-to-end.
    Limited-time (ends 6/20)
    100% money-back guarantee, no questions asked.